
Why It’s Time to Get More Curious About Effectiveness in the Private Development Finance Space
By Sara Nielsen, Co-Head of Climate Division
In the rapidly evolving landscape of development finance, foundations and impact investors have emerged as vital players. Their importance cannot be overstated. They bring private capital into sectors historically reliant on public funding, including infrastructure, education, health, environmental protection, and climate action. These contributions fill essential gaps that traditional development aid often cannot, especially in contexts where risk is perceived to be too high or returns too uncertain for conventional financiers.
The Growing Gap in Development Finance
According to the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) Financing Gap report, developing countries face an estimated US 4 trillion annual shortfall in financing the SDGs (source: UNCTAD World Investment Report 2023). In climate finance alone, the UNFCCC reports that to stay on track with the Paris Agreement, developing countries need at least USD 6 trillion by 2030, yet current flows are less than half that amount.
This is where impact investors and philanthropic foundations step in. They provide more flexible and patient capital, often in early-stage or frontier markets where few others are willing to go. Their ability to take on risk in ways that public and traditional financial institutions cannot make them a crucial bridge between public ambition and private action.
A Welcome but Opaque Addition
Recent reports suggest that the impact investing market reached 1.571 trillion in assets under management in 2024 (GIIN), with significant flows going toward key development sectors. Foundations, too, are investing billions of dollars globally. Their contributions are valuable and often celebrated as catalysts of innovation in sustainable development finance.
However, as someone who recently had a little time on my hands and started digging around impact investor and foundation websites, I found very little visible, rigorous evidence of real long-term impact.
Let me be clear! This is not to say that impact investors and foundations are not making a difference. However, it is worth noting that we should be asking harder questions. After reviewing annual reports, ESG disclosures, and impact statements, it is clear that most reporting focuses on outputs, not outcomes. Numbers such as “$XX million disbursed,” “X people served,” “X megawatts of clean energy installed,” “X number of sanitation devices installed” or “X tons of CO2 avoided” are prevalent, a very rosy picture of the private finance development aid space.
These reports also include great success stories, often from beneficiaries or businesses that received funding. Though they are compelling and offer insights into the potential power of these investments, they don’t replace a systematic and independent evaluation of whether the interventions are effective, efficient, sustainable, or scalable in the long term. And, they are most often not independently carried out, but based on self-assessment and self-reporting.
While I acknowledge that I haven’t reviewed every foundation or impact investor on Earth, the pattern across those I did explore, and in discussions with others in the space, suggests this is not an isolated issue.
The Evaluation Gap
Unlike UN agencies, Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs), and global environment funds such as the Global Environment Facility (GEF), Green Climate Fund (GCF), and Climate Investment Funds (CIF), the world of impact investing lacks a culture of independent evaluation. While impact investors often engage in impact measurement and reporting, few seem to apply rigorous, independent evaluation frameworks comparable to those used in public development finance institutions. Publicly funded institutions are required to commission regular, transparent evaluations, often conducted by independent evaluation offices or third-party private sector companies, and make the results publicly available. This could easily be adopted more rigorously in the impact investment space to provide higher visibility of long-term results. This level of scrutiny ensures accountability and helps decision-markers understand what works and why.
Many, if not most, impact investors and foundations currently operate without robust systems for independent evaluation. This is concerning, given that a significant portion of the capital they manage originates from public sources. For example, bilateral aid agencies such as KfW (Germany’s Development Bank), Norfund (Norway), SDC (Swiss), SIDA (Sweden) and LuxDev (Luxembourg), just to mention a few, have increasingly channeled development finance through private sector arms or via impact funds managed by private asset managers. These flows often come from taxpayer-backed development budgets, yet the level of transparency and public reporting on outcomes tends to be far lower than what is required of traditional public institutions. In recent years, pension funds have also begun allocating capital to impact funds, an encouraging development for the growth of the sector, but one that raises similar concerns.
After all, pension funds represent people’s savings, and just like taxpayer money, they warrant a high degree of scrutiny, accountability, and demonstrable impact.
I recognize it’s important not to generalize. Some leading funds, such as Acumen, Blue Orchard, and LeapFrog, do offer more detailed reporting and thoughtful insights into their work. However, even these often stop short of rigorous, independent evaluations that assess long-term effectiveness and sustainability.
In the case of foundations, funding streams differ. Most are financed through private capital, either corporate or philanthropic in origin, though some do receive public or co-invested funds. Regardless of the funding model, the end goal remains the same: to improve lives, enhance sustainability, and foster meaningful development.
With such noble goals and significant resources at stake, the need for deeper accountability and transparency across the entire ecosystem is timely and necessary.
Rare but Valuable Exceptions
To be fair, some evaluations are being done. At Baastel, where evaluation is our bread and butter, we’ve conducted a few, including the 2021 evaluation of the Private Finance Advisory Network (PFAN) under a UNIDO mandate. This was less about investment outcomes and more about assessing the effectiveness of the network in connecting SMEs with potential investors. Similarly, in 2022, we performed an Outcome Assessment for C40 and the L’Oréal Foundation, evaluating the impact of their Women4Climate program. Here, credit goes to the L’Oréal Foundation for seeking genuine learning about how their investment in women’s leadership was translating into measurable outcomes.
Similarly, a few major foundations are starting to break the mold. The Ford Foundation, has a unit dedicated to learning and has conducted multiple evaluations. The Rockefeller and Gates Foundations have also integrated evaluations into several of their initiatives. Even the MacArthur Foundation has assessed the effectiveness of its climate portfolio. These examples show that rigorous, independent evaluation is both feasible and valuable, even in the philanthropic space.
Still, these examples are the exception, not the rule.
So, why Isn’t Evaluation More Common?
There are several potential reasons:
- Lack of precedent: Unlike MDBs and UN agencies, impact investors and foundations may not have dedicated M&E (Monitoring & Evaluation) units.
- Perceived success: If reports and stories paint a picture of success, funders might not feel the need to dig deeper.
- Private sector culture: Evaluations can be seen as burdensome, especially in fast-moving investment environments.
- Limited capacity or incentives: Smaller foundations or funds may not have the capacity, or mandate, to commission independent evaluations.
But here’s the question: Shouldn’t we be more curious?
If we believe in the value of impact investing, and we should, then we must also believe in improving it. That starts with measuring not just what’s been spent or built, but what’s been achieved. Are people’s lives better in a meaningful and lasting ways? Are systems more resilient, more inclusive, more sustainable?
Evaluation, when done right, doesn’t hinder innovation, it fuels it.
Time to Raise the Bar
As public and private finance increasingly converge in the development space, the bar for transparency and accountability should rise, not fall. Impact investors and foundations have a unique role to play, and their contributions are needed now more than ever. But alongside capital must come a commitment to learning, reflection, and adaptation.
This is a call for more systematic, independent evaluations, not just for compliance on impact and ESG metrics, but for curiosity, for the pursuite of better outcomes.
Because if the goal is impact, we owe it to ourselves, and the people we aim to support, to know if we’re truly achieving it.
Sources
- https://unctad.org/publication/world-investment-report-2023
- https://unfccc.int/news/from-billions-to-trillions-setting-a-new-goal-on-climate-finance
- https://thegiin.org/publication/research/sizing-the-impact-investing-market-2024
- https://acumen.org/reports/2023-annual-report/
- https://www.blueorchard.com/impact/impact-report/
- https://impact2023.leapfroginvest.com
- https://www.fordfoundation.org/work/learning
- https://www.rockefellerfoundation.org/initiatives/urban-climate-health-action/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
- https://docs.gatesfoundation.org/documents/global-health-policy-strategy.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com
- https://www.macfound.org/media/files/cs_big_bet_2019_annual_report_final.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com
Besides the cited sources, this blog article is informed by scanning the websites of the following Impact Funds and Foundations, as well as through conversations with Impact Investors at the GIIN Investment Forum. The following Impact Firms and Foundations were scanned for information: Acumen, Blue Orchard, CEI Africa, LeapFrog, Triple Jump, Responsibility Investment AG, Capital + SAFI.