Mid-Term Review (MTR) for the “The Food Securities Fund: A fund to finance sustainable supply chains at scale in Emerging Markets” project
Clients:
Clients segment:
Region:
SDG:
Services:
Expertises:
Year(s):
Budget:
About
The Food Securities Fund (FSF) is a global blended finance fund launched in 2021 under the GEF Non-Grant Instrument (NGI) Program. Implemented by Conservation International (CI) and executed by Clarmondial, the Fund provides complementary credit to agricultural enterprises in emerging and developing markets to improve rural livelihoods while delivering positive environmental and social outcomes. FSF targets key constraints to sustainable agriculture such as limited access to affordable inputs and appropriate finance, using supply-chain–based lending, ESG screening, and a dual guarantee mechanism to reduce risk and unlock private investment.
The Mandate
At the midpoint of FSF’s implementation period (2021–2029), CI-GEF commissioned an independent Mid-Term Review (MTR). Conducted by Baastel, the MTR assessed progress toward the achievement of intended outputs, outcomes, and early indications of impact. It also examined the sustainability of interventions; the adequacy of governance, management, and coordination arrangements; the robustness of monitoring and evaluation systems; the quality and efficiency of implementation; and compliance with environmental and social safeguards. The review was designed to support both accountability and evidence-based adaptive management over the remaining implementation period.
Role of Baastel
Baastel provides independent analytical expertise to assess progress toward the intended results and early impacts of the FSF. Our role is to examine the effectiveness and sustainability of the Fund’s blended finance model, while reviewing the governance, management and monitoring and evaluation systems supporting implementation. The work also generates evidence-based findings and recommendations to support learning and inform course correction.
Our Approach and Scope
- Independent mid-term review in line with OECD-DAC standards, CI-GEF Evaluation Policy, and GEF IEO guidance
- Application of a theory-based, participatory, gender-sensitive, and utilization-focused approach, anchored in a refined Theory of Change
- Use of mixed methods for data collection and triangulation, including document review, key informant interviews, focus group discussions, observation, and a field mission in Côte d’Ivoire that was selected by the team as part of the process for the field mission
- Analysis of evidence to assess results, sustainability, safeguards, and implementation of quality, and formulated actionable recommendations.
Key Findings & Recommendations
The MTE confirms the strategic soundness and operational relevance of the Fund, underscoring its ability to translate global social and environmental goals and national development priorities into targeted investment decisions. Its blended finance structure fills a critical financing gap in sustainable agriculture, particularly in pre-harvest and early-stage lending, segments underserved by traditional financiers. However, the Fund’s limited capital base has constrained its ability to scale. In this context, some of Baastel’s report recommendations include:
- Enhance Transparency and Streamline Investor Communication by striking a better balance between cautious disclosure and transparency in investor communications
- Publicly Disseminate the Fund’s Positive Results and Impacts on Behalf of Clarmondial given Clarmondial’s promotional restrictions under Luxembourg law. CI could play a more active role in communicating the Fund’s mission and achievements
- Strengthen Fundraising Capacity when resources allow: once the Fund grows and allows for Fund management autonomy, consider hiring a dedicated fundraising professional to support capital-raising efforts, donor engagement, and investor relations—freeing Clarmondial’s current core team to focus on portfolio and fund operations
Assigned team
- Quality Advisor: Olivier Beucher
- Team Leader: Alexandre Daoust
- Analyst: Oriane Althaus
- National consultant Côte d’Ivoire