Mid-term evaluation of the GEF-UNDP project in Costa Rica, GEF Sustainable Cities Programme

Clients:

United Nations Development Programme (UNDP)

Clients segment:

International and Regional Organizations, Financial Institutions and Private Sector

Region:

Latin America

Country:

Costa Rica

SDG:

Sustainable cities & communities, Climate action

Services:

Monitoring & Evaluation, Urban development

Expertises:

Climate, Nature, Economic

Year(s):

2025

Budget:

USD 25,000

Context

The Sustainable Cities Integrated Program (SCIP) is a GEF multi-country impact program designed to support cities in adopting integrated urban planning approaches that deliver global environmental benefits. Under GEF-7, SCIP promoted low-carbon, resilient, and nature-positive urban development through policy reform, strategic investments, innovative financing, capacity building, and knowledge sharing. The program aims to address key urban drivers of climate change, biodiversity loss, land degradation, and pollution by supporting systemic urban transformation at scale. As part of the SCIP, the project “Transitioning to an urban green economy and delivering global environmental benefits” targets decarbonization, climate resilience and sustainable urban transformation in the Great Metropolitan Area (GAM) of Costa Rica, through fiscal and policy reform, evidence-based integrated urban planning, and investments in low-carbon, resilient, and nature-positive urban development. 

The Mandate

The project is structured around five components covering policy reform and planning, sustainable investments, innovative financing and scaling-up, knowledge sharing and partnerships, and monitoring and evaluation. Implemented over five years, it represents a total investment of USD 109.4 million, including USD 10.3 million from the GEF, and aims to generate measurable global environmental benefits in terms of greenhouse gas mitigation, land restoration, biodiversity conservation, climate resilience and improved urban environmental management. Baastel was engaged to conduct the Mid-Term Review (MTR) of the project as part of its monitoring and evaluation plan.  

Role of Baastel

Baastel provides independent expertise to evaluate the progress made towards the project’s defined objectives and outcomes. Our role supports adaptive management by identifying implementation challenges, emerging results and potential corrective measures to inform decisions on project restructuring or budget reallocations. The engagement also helps inform UNDP, national partners and the GEF on project performance and key lessons at mid-term.  

Our Approach and Scope

  • Participatory mid-term evaluation, using both qualitative and quantitative methods 
  • Assessment of project performance against agreed evaluation criteria, based on documented evidence, stakeholder consultations and direct observation. 
  • Identification of implementation challenges and lessons learned, and formulated recommendations for corrective actions 
  • Delivery of the Inception Report, a Preliminary Findings Presentation, and Draft and Final Evaluation Reports, aligned to GEF-UNDP guidelines 

Key Recommendations

  • Strengthen project components by focusing on systems and structures that support sustainability, scaling and replication of results. 
  • Address strategic but potentially sensitive issues critical for the GAM’s transition toward a sustainable city, in line with the project’s Theory of Change. 
  • Better integrate urban traffic calming and ecological restoration interventions within a coherent spatial approach. 
  • Reinforce the technical and financial sustainability of project results through expanded training, stronger institutional partnerships, and the Sustainable Urban Renewal Strategy, including public–private partnerships. 
  • Promote the political sustainability of project outcomes through engagement with municipalities and the Legislative Assembly, including advocacy ahead of the 2026 government transition. 
  • Integrate climate change adaptation more systematically into project interventions and strengthen technical assistance to support implementation. 

Assigned team

  • Team Leader: Jon Garcia 
  • External Evaluator