Independent External Evaluation of the Approach to Projects for WMO
Clients:
Clients segment:
Region:
SDG:
Services:
Expertises:
Year(s):
Budget:
About
The World Meteorological Organization (WMO) is a specialized agency of the United Nations responsible for promoting international cooperation in meteorology, climatology, hydrology, and related Earth system sciences. In recent years, WMO has experienced a rapid expansion of its extra-budgetary project portfolio, increasing the importance of effective project governance, strategic alignment, and operational delivery to support the organization’s Vision 2030 and Member State priorities.
The Mandate
Between October 2024 and April 2025, Baastel was commissioned to conduct an independent external evaluation of WMO’s approach to projects. The mandate responded to institutional concerns related to the growing scale and complexity of WMO’s project portfolio and the need to strengthen strategic coherence, governance arrangements, and operational effectiveness in project implementation. The evaluation covered all projects in WMO’s active portfolio, with the exception of the Systematic Observations Financing Facility (SOFF) and the Voluntary Cooperation Programme, as agreed during the inception phase. It assessed WMO’s project management approach across strategic, governance, and operational levels, with reference to international good practices.
Role of Baastel
Baastel provides analytical expertise to assess WMO’s project management approach in the context of its expanding extra-budgetary portfolio. Our work examines the alignment between projects, the WMO Vision 2030 and Member State priorities, while identifying systemic strengths, gaps and risks affecting project quality, efficiency and accountability. Baastel also supports the formulation of practical and actionable recommendations to inform institutional reform and guide WMO’s future approach to project scope, scale and management.
Our Approach and Scope
- Design and implementation of a utilization-focused evaluation, guided by international good practices, including the Project Management Institute’s Organizational Project Management framework
- Management of mixed-methods data collection, combining document review, interviews, surveys, and focus discussions, and organized a visit at WMO Headquarters (in Geneva) and selected regional offices in Africa and the Caribbean/Latin America
- Consolidation and triangulation of qualitative and quantitative evidence to identify systemic strengths, gaps, and risks, to formulate clear, actionable recommendations based on the analysis
- Presentation and validation of interim and final findings with WMO senior management and governance bodies, incorporating feedback into the final outputs
Key Recommendations
- Define and operationalize a strategic vision for project implementation
- Strengthen governance and oversight mechanisms
- Strengthen project selection, design and approval processes
- Institutionalize a MERL framework for project management
- Optimize Administrative & Financial Processes
- Develop Long-Term Capacity Building for Project Management
Assigned team
- Team Leader: Evan Green
- Evaluators: Monica Torres, Nadia Perez