External evaluation of the Sustainable Development Analysis and Advice of the French Development Agency

Clients:

French Development Agency (AFD)

Clients segment:

Governments, Agencies and Communities

Region:

Global

SDG:

Climate action, Life on land

Services:

Monitoring & Evaluation

Expertises:

Climate, Nature, Social, Economic

Year(s):

2025

Budget:

EUR 99,228

About

The Sustainable Development Analysis and Advice (AADD, for its French acronym) mechanism was introduced by the French Development Agency (AFD, for its French acronym) in 2014 to better integrate sustainable development considerations into its financing decisions. The mechanism assesses the expected impacts of projects across key sustainable development dimensions, including biodiversity, climate, social cohesion, gender equality, governance, and the economy, using a structured analysis grid and an independent opinion process. Over time, AADD has evolved to align with AFD’s strategic orientations and has become a central tool for AFD’s alignment with the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), including for sustainable bond eligibility. 

The Mandate

After ten years of implementation and several methodological and operational evolutions, AFD commissioned Baastel to conduct an external evaluation of the AADD mechanism. The evaluation aimed to take stock of the mechanism’s functioning, robustness, and contributions, and to provide an external perspective to support institutional learning. While the analysis covered the mechanism from its inception (2013-2014), the evaluation focused primarily on the 2018-2023 period, during which major revisions to the analysis grid and operational processes were introduced and the mechanism was extended to AFD subsidiaries. 

Role of Baastel

Baastel  mobilises analytical expertise to assess the robustness of the AADD mechanism, including its methodological tools, processes, governance and organizational arrangements. The work examines how the mechanism contributes to operationalizing AFD’s strategic ambition on alignment with sustainable development and generates lessons learned and forward-looking recommendations to inform improvements in the short, medium and long term, while supporting institutional learning on the functioning and evolution of the AADD mechanism. 

Our Approach and Scope

  • Retrospective evaluation of the AADD mechanism, with a focus on the 2018-2023 period 
  • Analysis of multiple mechanism dimensions, including Sustainable development analyses and opinions, methodological tools (analysis grid and criteria), processes, governance, and organizational arrangements, support functions and collaborations 
  • Contribution assessment of AADD to aligning AFD-financed operations with sustainable development objectives beyond the SDGs alone 
  • Development of findings, lessons learned, and forward-looking recommendations, including proposals for participatory and ownership-oriented methodological approaches, taking into account operational constraints faced by AFD teams 

Key Findings & Recommendations

  • The evaluation confirms the structuring role of the AADD mechanism in aligning the AFD Group with the SDGs, through the following drivers: strategic commitment, governance integrating the SDGs, and dissemination of an internal culture of sustainable development 
  • As part of AFD POS5 (2025–2030), which aims to make AFD “100% SDG-compliant,” the AADD is set to evolve from an ex-ante analysis tool to a strategic portfolio management instrument, contributing to the quality, impact, and accountability of operations 
  • The evaluation highlights the need to better align the AADD with result-monitoring mechanisms in order to document impact trajectories more robustly. The integration of AFD, Proparco, and Expertise France in a Group also implies a gradual harmonization of analysis, reporting, and project selection practices to ensure data comparability and consistency of standards 
  • Finally, in view of the growing demands of sustainable finance and the entry into force of the CSRD in 2026, the system will need to strengthen the standardization, traceability, and auditability of ESG data, in close coordination with the Group’s reporting functions 

Assigned team

  • Quality Advisor: Gaétan Quesne  
  • Team Leader
  • Deputy Team Leader: Cecilia Moreno 
  • Senior Evaluator  
  • Evaluator